4 Days in Anguilla: First-Timer Itinerary

4 Days in Anguilla: First-Timer Itinerary

Four days is the sweet spot for a first Anguilla trip: enough time for the three headline beaches AND the payoff most short trips skip entirely, an offshore cay lunch on day three and Scilly Cay’s grilled lobster at Island Harbour on day four. Anguilla is a British Overseas Territory, not a slice of neighboring St Martin, and almost everyone arrives through Sint Maarten’s Princess Juliana Airport (SXM) before finishing the last leg by ferry. Prices run in East Caribbean dollars pegged at EC$2.70 to the US dollar, though menus quote USD directly, and this island is upscale by deliberate policy, not a cheap one. Only got two or three days? See the 2-day and 3-day itineraries. Staying longer? The 5-day , 6-day and 7-day versions add a St Martin day trip and more unstructured beach time on top of this same route. Our Anguilla travel guide covers the planning details this post doesn’t repeat.

Book these before you go:

Day-by-day at a glance

Day Focus Travel time Daily cost (approx)
1 SXM arrival, ferry over, settle in, Shoal Bay East Ferry 20-25 min Marigot to Blowing Point; taxi hops 15-20 min roughly $150-250
2 Meads Bay morning, Rendezvous Bay beach-bar evening Taxi hops 15-25 min around the West End roughly $150-300+
3 Offshore cay day: Sandy Island or Prickly Pear Boat transfer 5-15 min from Sandy Ground roughly $200-300
4 Scilly Cay lobster lunch, Little Bay or island loop by car Taxi or drive 20-30 min to Island Harbour; full loop roughly 45 min roughly $200-350

Day 1: touchdown, the ferry hop, and Shoal Bay East

Land at Princess Juliana International Airport (SXM) on Sint Maarten first, a genuine first-timer surprise, then taxi to the ferry pier at Marigot: the airport sits on the Dutch side and the boat leaves from the French side, so budget a separate transfer between them. The public ferry runs eight scheduled crossings a day, takes 20 to 25 minutes, and costs roughly $30 for an adult one way plus a departure tax that genuinely varies by source, confirm the current figure at gov.ai before you budget the day. Flew American’s nonstop from Miami into Clayton J. Lloyd instead? Then you skip the ferry entirely.

Clear customs, collect a rental car if you’re planning the day four island loop (a temporary local driving permit is required, roughly $25 for three months or $15 for a short stay, bought straight through the rental company, and driving here is on the left, the British-territory rule that catches first-timers off guard given right-hand-drive St Martin sits a short ferry ride away). Drop your bags at a West End base near Meads Bay or in Sandy Ground, then get straight to Shoal Bay East for the afternoon: a two-mile run of powder-white sand with reef right off the shore and a line of beachfront bar shacks for lunch. Stay put for dinner at one of those shacks, day one works best when you don’t overplan it.

Day 2: Meads Bay’s glossy morning into Rendezvous Bay’s beach-bar sunset

Spend the morning at Meads Bay, the glossiest stretch of sand on the island and home to Blanchards, whose casual Beach Shack arm runs 11:30am to 8pm and skips Sunday, no reservation needed, though the main restaurant next door does want one. By early afternoon, move to Rendezvous Bay on the south-west coast, a long, quiet beach with a clear sightline across the channel to St Martin and two genuine destination bars of its own, Sunshine Shack and the Dune Preserve, the latter owned by reggae musician Bankie Banx and home to the annual Moonsplash festival. If your dates happen to land on a Sunday, several beach bars island-wide run a weekly “jump-up,” a live-music beach party worth chasing down.

Day 3: your first offshore cay, Sandy Island or Prickly Pear

This is the day that separates a 2-day trip from a 4-day one. Sandy Island is a tiny sandbar islet roughly a 5-minute boat ride from Sandy Ground, with its own restaurant, hammocks, and loungers right on the sand. Prickly Pear is a slightly bigger cay with two long-running beach restaurants, Agatha’s and Johnno’s, plus better snorkeling and shade under thatch umbrellas. Either works, book the crossing above rather than turning up and hoping for a spot on a boat.

Back on the mainland by mid-afternoon, swing through The Valley, the low-key capital, and the Heritage Collection Museum if it’s open, hours and admission for this small, locally-run museum aren’t reliably published, so treat a visit as a bonus rather than a fixed plan. Close the day with dinner back near your base, you’ve earned a quiet one after a full day on the water.

Day 4: Scilly Cay’s lobster lunch, then Little Bay or a full island loop

Head to Island Harbour on the quieter east end for Scilly Cay, the island’s classic wave-it-down lunch spot: stand on the pier and a dinghy motors across to collect you, no phone booking involved. Grilled lobster and crayfish are the reason people build a whole day around this place, but it historically opens only a few specific days a week, commonly cited as Wednesday, Friday and Sunday, so confirm the current open days before you commit your last full day to it.

Pair the lunch with whichever fits your afternoon. Little Bay is a secluded north-coast cove with genuinely good snorkeling, reachable by boat or a rope-assisted scramble down the cliffside, treat the rope route as needing a current-conditions check rather than a guaranteed DIY option. Or take the rental car (with that temporary permit from day one) on a full loop of the island, an easy 45 minutes end to end, swinging past Maundays Bay’s exclusive curve of sand on the far west end and back along the East End’s quieter fishing-village stretch. Either choice closes out a first Anguilla trip that covered the beaches, a cay, and the island’s most local meal.

Is 4 days enough for a first Anguilla trip?

Yes, comfortably. Anguilla has no interior sights, no mountains, and a roughly 45-minute end-to-end drive, so three headline beaches, one offshore cay, and Scilly Cay’s lobster lunch make a genuinely complete first trip. A longer stay buys pace and a St Martin day trip, not a longer list of checklist sights the island doesn’t have.

Is Scilly Cay worth building day four around?

Yes, more than a second straight beach day would be. It’s a genuine local institution, wave-down pickup, grilled lobster, heavy-handed rum punch, and it only runs a few days a week, so it earns a dedicated slot rather than a maybe-if-we-pass-by mention. Just confirm its current open days before you lock day four in around it.

Is Anguilla safe for a first-timer?

Mostly yes, with one caveat worth stating plainly. The UK Foreign Office’s current advisory for Anguilla flags a documented 2025 uptick in gang-related gun crime and robbery alongside its otherwise routine guidance, so check the current advisory before you go and keep ordinary city-level caution. Day to day, strong sun, rip currents on windier stretches, and cost are the more likely issues for a beach-focused first-timer.

What to sort before you land

The East Caribbean dollar (EC$/XCD) is the official currency, pegged at $1 to EC$2.70 since 1976, but US dollars work everywhere and most tourist prices are quoted in USD directly, so you rarely need to think in EC$ at all. What you do need to plan for is cost: Anguilla runs no cruise ships, no casinos, and no high-rise hotels by deliberate policy, which keeps it upscale and genuinely pricier than most of its neighbors, not a budget stop. Check ivisitanguilla.com for current beach and cay-transfer details before you lock the schedule in, and keep a bit of physical cash on hand for the cay boats and Scilly Cay’s dinghy pickup.